ShortList is supported by you, our amazing readers. When you click through the links on our site and make a purchase we may earn a commission. Learn more

The best alternative Christmas movies that will put you in the festive mood

In Bruges will get you in f-in festive spirit, okay?

22 December 2023

Sometimes when looking for a Christmas movie to watch it's better to go down the alternative route.

Especially if you find yourself groaning at the idea of putting on one of the classic best Christmas movies on... yet again... For the third time this week.

We feel your pain. However, the real range of Christmas movies is much wider than you might think. You just have to squint a bit, and basically accept that if a film is set at Christmas, or there's a Christmas tree in a scene or two, it counts.

And while it’s case closed when it comes to the question: 'is Die Hard a Christmas movie?', there are plenty more films out there that have the feeling of the festive season but aren’t strictly about Christmas - as this best alternative Christmas movies list proves.

Whether it’s a snow-tinged setting, a lump-in-your-throat feeling when you watch it or it’s a movie that’s watched over the Xmas period without fail, we’ve compiled the best Christmas movies that aren’t Christmas movies.
The hope is: if you don’t want to watch something with Ol’ Saint Nic in, these are a damn good Crimbo compromise.

Best alternative Christmas movies

1. Gremlins

Ah, Gremlins. The anti-Christmas movie that has one of the creepiest stories ever told about Santa getting stuck down a chimney. Couple this with Gizmo playing keyboard with a Santa hat on, numerous gremlins carol singing and Mogwai being the ultimate ‘a pet isn’t just for Christmas’ present and Gremlins is as festive as your Uncle Charles’ ruddied face trying to sing to Fairytale of New York while his mouth is full of volovants.

Image Credit: Warner Bros

55
7
Thanks for voting

2. In Bruges

Nothing says Christmas more than a heady dose of existential dread, and that’s exactly what you get with In Bruges. Set over the Christmas period and focusing on a pair of hitmen shipped to Bruges, for the most part the movie is about two killers trying to figure out whether they should be pardoned (or, in other words, on the naught or nice list) for the amount of sin they’ve committed in their lives, all to the backdrop of the fairytale architecture of the Belgium town.

Image Credit: Universal Pictures

47
9
Thanks for voting

3. Batman Returns

Set amongst the festive season, Batman Returns oozes frosty appeal. It’s a snow-flecked movie packed with red, white and black (the only colour Tim Burton seemed to use in the ‘90s) and its most memorable scene is the tree-lighting ceremony where a white-haired Max Shreck is flanked by evil circus people jumping out of oversized presents.

Image Credit: Warner Bros

45
8
Thanks for voting

4. Lethal Weapon

We all know Mel Gibson is a big fan of the, er, big guy in the sky, so it’s apt that Lethal Weapon is set at a time when Christmas is in town, even if that town is LA. Again, this is a movie with an iconic scene set to Jingle Bell Rock and Riggs even spends Christmas with Roger “I’m getting too old for this shit” Murtaugh’s family. There’s even a ruck in a Christmas tree lot, midway through the movie.

Image Credit: Warner Bros

40
11
Thanks for voting

5. Trading Places

Trading Places is set mere days before the big day and features one of Dan Aykroyd’s best scenes ever, where he is drunk and dressed as a bedraggled Santa Claus, crashing his old job's Christmas party and stuffing buffet meat into the big pockets of his outfit. Which is pretty much how we act when the Boxing Day buffet is unleashed.

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures

37
10
Thanks for voting

6. Edward Scissorhands

Another Burton classic. Christmas doesn’t come into play in Edward Scissorhands until the end of the movie but it feels like a festive film throughout, especially when Edward (Johnny Depp) cuts up the ice statue for Kim (Winona Ryder) and the scene when he’s trying to wrap some presents and he has a bit of tape on his 'scissor' hands that he just can’t get rid of. We may have made that last bit up.

Image Credit: 20th Century Fox

28
19
Thanks for voting

7. Rocky IV

Rocky IV takes place in the middle of a Siberian winter and that’s all we need for it to feel like a Christmas movie. But there’s more: the main fight takes place between Rocky and Ivan Drago on Christmas Day, which scuppers both of their plans to overeat and sup their weight in port but it makes for fascinating viewing. Oh, and Paulie is given a terrible present of Sico, a rusty robot butler which sums up Christmas to us.

Image Credit: MGM / UA Entertainment

24
17
Thanks for voting

8. 12 Monkeys

If you’re looking for an excuse to stick a sci-fi classic on, remind the family 12 Monkeys is set at Christmas Eve. OK, so it’s also set in 2035 and 1990, and is about a virus that all but wipes out the Earth’s population in 1996. But we do get to see a Christmas tree in an airport so it’s definitely a Christmas movie of sorts. Mildly mind-bending and super-engaging time travel features heavily in one of Terry Gilliam’s best films. It packs a lot into its just-over-2hr run time.

4
0
Thanks for voting

9. Iron Man 3

Even Marvel has admitted that Iron Man 3 is pretty much a Christmas film. It has all the trappings: it’s set over the holiday season and Tony Stark is visited by a number of ‘ghosts’ from his past and he comes out the other side redeemed and a new, better person. Oh, and a lot of it is just him and a slightly annoying kid which adds a good deal of schmaltz to proceedings.

Image Credit: Marvel

23
20
Thanks for voting

You know what makes a Christmas movie truly festive? Home invasion. David Harbour stars as a Santa who finds himself caught up in a violent robbery while delivering presents. And that doesn't fly, but the criminals sure will. John Leguizamo stars as head baddie Jimmy Martinez in a fairly gore-soaked flick that still, somehow, manages to feel quite festive. It's Christmas spirit for the grinch crowd.

4
2
Thanks for voting

11. Eyes Wide Shut

Of course Eyes Wide Shut is an adjacent Christmas movie. It’s set over the festive period and begins with the pair coming home after a Christmas party, where they make love while fantasising about other people. Personally we prefer a kebab and snuggling up to a sick bowl on the sofa post Xmas party drinks but we don’t think Kubrick would have made a movie about that.

Image Credit: Warner Bros

14
23
Thanks for voting

12. Mean Girls

“Ugh, lip gloss!” You will never be able to hear Jingle Bell Rock the same way again once you watch Santa’s Helpers (AKA The Plastics) doing a dance to it in Mean Girls. It’s a perfect, if completely misjudged, routine for a school talent show. Mean Girls is a fantastic film to watch any time of the year but it has enough Christmas in it to watch repeatedly in December.

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures

30
49
Thanks for voting

SOMETHING MISSING FROM OUR SHORTLIST?

Tell us about it, and if enough people agree we'll add it in.